Is “Good Enough” Really Good?

I love this quote.

When I do good, I feel good.  When I do bad, I feel bad. That’s my religion.  –Abraham Lincoln

I always try to do the right thing.  Ok, I’m lying.  I want to think that I always try do the right thing, and I want other people to think that too.  I sometimes don’t even try do the right thing in a given situation; often I do.  And then there are moments that just leave me with questions.

This week I am thinking about something that happened.  What, is unimportant.  What is driving me to write about it, other than sleeping children, is an obsession with my response–was I a good person in that moment or a bad person?  If I feel bad, does it mean I was bad–or is it more complicated than that?  When I feel good, does it really mean I’ve done enough?

As I do with all things monumental and profound, I turn to the Internet. While mom’s insight is good, it is limited to a phone call.  And not many friends want to dissect my every motivation and action for hours.  My unrestricted access to the Internet is keeping this issue alive.

I Google “how to be a good person,” then “how to be a good Jewish person”–in case there are big differences.  Interestingly, there are many sites devoted to being or becoming a good person.  There is even a test.  (I didn’t take it; it might spoil the fun.)

I find something and keep reading, relating to each paragraph, sometimes happily and sometimes with a bit of regret.  I find this section particularly wonderful, simple, confusing in light of my current confusion.

When confronted with a situation that leaves you uncertain as to whether you are taking the right action, ask yourself one question: “What is motivating me to act in this way, my yetzer tov (good inclination) or my yetzer hara (evil inclination)?” Just answering this question will usually determine the appropriate course of action. –Rabbi Joseph Telushkin (“13 Ways To Become a Good Person: Jewish pointers on living a good and ethical life,” Reform Judaism Magazine, Spring 2006)

This week I am in the grey area between feeling I am a good person, and thinking I am bad.  Recent experiences have shaken my view of myself.  I am not someone who does well in the grey area.  I like going through my day without drama, with most things going my way.  Here is a shocking fact: I like life to be easy.  I am a very good person when things are easy.  Most days are good enough for me. (It helps that I’ve lowered both my standards and the bar of what I call civilized behavior.)  When situations fall out of my comfort zone, I get nervous.

I don’t follow a religion, yet I find many writings of religious scholars comforting.  There is   value to me in both the Torah and the New Testament.  There seems to be a universal good we all aspire to reach; I want to know how close we have to get to that determination for the bell to ring.

Perfection is ultimately unattainable.  It seems, to my disappointment, that much of life is the grey area–we do our best knowing we will fail miserably at times, be only adequate at others. I repeat: there are times I don’t even try; I do what I want and hope the universe will give me a pass.

I will force myself to end here.  There are school applications to be done, dishwashers to load and wine to be opened.  This quote perhaps makes clear the reason for my angst.

Wisdom is knowing what to do next; virtue is doing it.  -David Star Jordan, The Philosophy of Despair

Sometimes I know and often I am confused about the next right thing; sometimes I just ignore that wisdom.  This is probably true for others as well.  I can’t be alone in wondering if I’ve followed through on all the next things on any given day.  Of course, there are days I know I have not. Tonight I wonder: what is the acceptable margin of error?

(Forget what I said.  This is perfect.  And it makes me look like a good person.)

This entry was posted in Family Life, It's All About Me, New York City Living and Coping. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Is “Good Enough” Really Good?

  1. JD says:

    I totally hear you on this. I obsess about my reactions to situations when I am unhappy with how I reacted – whether I overreacted, underreacted, ignored, wasn’t truly nice … there is a mom in my playgroup who rubs me the wrong way. I am pretty sure she means well, but she irritates me a lot. She’s criticized me before in a very passive-aggressive way, which sounds like she has bad intent, but I really don’t think she does – she is just very socially awkward. I think she may have OCD and can’t control what she says at times because she HAS to say it. Even knowing all this, I find it so hard to be nice to her at times. I feel badly when I’m not. I think, “How would I feel if someone did this to me?” and know I’d feel terrible. But sometimes, after a night of interrupted sleep, grouchy kids, and a husband traveling for two days, I just can’t be nice. I know I’m not perfect. I know sometimes good enough has to do. But I still feel terrible when I’m not nice.

    • hi JD! re: the stroller post– I realize I got a little defensive about the wine hanging from the mommy hook! what’s up with that? the pics are all with hipstamatic for iPhone. i have no clue what film, lens and flash I am using at any given time (it gives you options), but I just love that even weird, bad pictures look interesting–and all my photos are in the weird to bad category. always.
      thank you for all the love tonight! I knew I liked you. 🙂

      When I read your locker room story, it totally hit me in the same place. I think it’s important of course to consider how we treat others–but also to forgive ourselves for being imperfect. Both are valuable lessons that I want my kids to learn– And always, our first priority is our kids, even before other people’s feelings– so it gets bizarrely complicated. I am working on another post right now that is making me think about these things (more specifically about how girls treat girls)… It’s painful–and having little girls now makes it such a heart wrenching, stomach turning subject for me…
      Lack of sleep pretty much destroys all my best intentions, by the way!

Leave a Reply to JD Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s